Victoria Police say Yemini allegedly failed to comply with a move-on direction near the State Library on Thursday, 12 November, and was later arrested on suspicion of hindering police.
Yemini says he was interviewing people near a student walkout against Pauline Hanson and One Nation when officers intervened. He was handcuffed, driven away and released without charge on both occasions.
David John Walsh, who served 37 years in the Queensland Police Service and regularly policed street protests during the Joh Bjelke-Petersen era, called for Victoria Police to explain the grounds for each intervention. Walsh based his account on a livestream of the protest.
“When someone is handcuffed, put into a police vehicle and taken away, the public deserves a clear explanation of the legal grounds,” Walsh wrote.
“If there is relevant conduct the livestream did not show, Victoria Police should explain it. On what I saw, he was interviewing a protester.” he said
Police cite move-on direction and alleged hindering
In a statement reported by Rebel News, Victoria Police said officers detained Yemini near the State Library at about 3.35pm after he allegedly failed to comply with a direction to move on.
Police said officers took him to a nearby location. When he returned, police allege he tried to pass directly through a group of officers. They arrested him over the alleged offence of hindering police and released him a short time later. The force said its investigation was ongoing.
According to Yemini an officer initially raised concerns about a breach of the peace while he was conducting an interview. The police statement as published by Rebel News gave the alleged failure to comply as the reason for the first detention and did not say what prompted the original move-on direction.
That is the decision Walsh wants explained, along with why officers used handcuffs and took Yemini away.
Walsh says he understood the need for police to act firmly when crowds became difficult. His concern was what happens when protesters demand that police remove a reporter. “Disliking a journalist or his questions should not give anyone a veto over his presence,” he wrote.
Legal demand follows earlier police apology
Rebel News reports that Yemini’s lawyer, Justin Quill, delivered a letter of demand to Chief Commissioner Mike Bush on Tuesday, 17 November.
The letter seeks compensation, legal costs, a written apology and an investigation into the officers involved. It asks Victoria Police to respond by Monday, 23 November. The outlet says Yemini’s lawyers are preparing a statement of claim.
In 2022, Victoria Police issued a written apology acknowledging that officers had wrongly arrested and detained Yemini while he was reporting for Rebel News at earlier protests. Walsh said that history made him expect greater care when officers dealt with Yemini again.
“After 37 years wearing a police uniform, criticising fellow officers does not come lightly to me,” Walsh wrote. “But that experience is precisely why I cannot simply shrug at what I watched.”


